Second opinion for a painful or failed hip or knee replacement

Short answer
If your hip or knee replacement is painful, stiff, unstable or loose, or you have been told you need revision surgery, I can review the cause and discuss the options with you. I review your history and available investigations, with further tests where required, before discussing whether revision is appropriate.
Key facts
- Assessment may include X-rays, CT, blood tests and joint aspiration where indicated. (Source: My revision hip and knee guides)
- Infected revisions are done at UHCW only. (Source: My revision knee guide)
- Private consultations are available at Meriden and Nuffield Warwickshire for insured and self-pay patients. (Source: Contact and booking)
- Revision is tailored to the cause of failure, from an insert exchange to a full revision. (Source: My revision knee guide)
Who is a second opinion for?
I see people with pain, stiffness, instability or loosening after a hip or knee replacement, including people who have been told they need revision surgery.
What do I review?
I review your symptoms, history and previous replacement, together with available X-rays, scans and blood tests.
- X-rays to assess the replacement and alignment.
- CT scans where the anatomy is complex or revision planning is required.
- Blood tests, including inflammatory markers such as CRP, when infection is suspected.
- Joint aspiration where infection around the replacement is a possibility.
Does a second opinion mean I need another operation?
The decision depends on the cause of your symptoms. Revision may involve changing an insert, a single component or all components. Where stiffness is the main problem, releasing scar tissue (arthrolysis) may be considered rather than replacing the implant.
How do I share records or book?
Contact me through the contact page, by phone or by email to book and arrange how to share your existing records, X-rays, scans and blood test results.
What if infection is suspected?
I investigate for infection with blood tests and joint aspiration where indicated, and discuss complex cases with the multidisciplinary team. Infected revisions are done at UHCW only. If the joint becomes hot, red and increasingly swollen, or you feel unwell, seek urgent medical help rather than waiting for a routine second opinion.
My approach
- I establish why the replacement is painful or failing before discussing revision.
- I tailor any revision to the failed components, bone loss and soft tissues.
- I discuss complex cases at the regional complex arthroplasty MDT (Warwick and Worcester) and the Coventry & Warwickshire Bone Infection Group.
- I am an executive member of BAJIS and collaborate with microbiology for infected cases.
Who I don't treat
- I do not offer sports knee or soft-tissue surgery (ACL reconstruction, meniscus surgery or arthroscopy). For those problems, I suggest seeing a sports knee specialist.
- A routine second-opinion appointment is not a substitute for urgent medical help when infection is suspected.
What might the assessment lead to?
| Problem | What I assess | Options already described in my revision guides |
|---|---|---|
| Loosening, wear or instability | Which components have failed and the degree of bone loss | Insert or head and liner exchange, component revision or full revision |
| Stiffness | Movement and soft tissues | Arthrolysis may be considered rather than replacing the implant |
| Possible infection | Blood tests and joint aspiration where indicated | DAIR, one-stage or two-stage revision; infected revision at UHCW only |
Cost, insurance and booking
I see insured and self-pay patients. Contact me to arrange a consultation, discuss the next steps and request a quote. Send an enquiry or call 024 7661 2681.
